This is my respectful, non-combative, non-confrontational (that’s for Promeus) response to Charlie Angus’s Substack article about a National Post opinion piece that called out the antisemitic statement that Avi Lewis made on the eve of Yom Kippur.

You can read that article HERE
To sum it up, on the eve of one of the holiest nights of the year for Jews, Mr. Lewis released a statement that essentially attached responsibility for the devastation of Gaza to all Jews.
At a time when attacks against Canadian Jews are becoming more frequent and more violent (that very night there was a shooting in Belleville - a massacre was prevented by a very brave police officer), statements such as this do nothing but fuel hatred against Jews.
Journalist Yoni Goldstein published an article in the National Post lambasting Lewis for this statement, and provided biblical context in how to deal with Jews who are a danger to their community. And then all the antisemites lashed out at Mr. Goldstein and accused him of calling for violence against Mr. Lewis. Mr. Angus appears to feel that the article crossed a line.
First of all, Mr. Angus has no credibility as to what constitutes antisemitism as many of his own statements and actions in the past have crossed well into that territory.

Asking him to weigh in on whether Mr. Lewis committed an act of antisemitism would be akin to asking the fox to guard the henhouse.

Mr. Lewis clearly made an antisemitic statement when he blamed Jews in general for what he incorrectly labelled a genocide in Gaza. He posted on X:
“For Jewish people, the personal has always been political and the political always personal. This year I’m reflecting on the fact that we failed to do our part to stop an ongoing genocide committed in our name.”
The NDP’s own accepted definition of antisemitism includes holding Canadian Jews responsible for events beyond their control. The fact that the party has not demanded a retraction from its leader is a testament to the depths to which it has sunk.
As an aside, I’m disappointed that someone who held a seat in Parliament for so many years doesn’t even know how many Jewish leaders the Federal party has had. Mr. Lewis is one. His grandfather David was another. I would challenge Mr. Angus to name the third to whom he makes reference.
Avi Lewis is someone that many of my colleagues would classify as a useful idiot, a Jew who runs cover for antisemites. When challenged, the racists point to people like Mr. Lewis and say “well he’s Jewish and I’m agreeing with him so I can’t be an antisemite.” I personally dislike this term because it implies that the figurehead is not intelligent.
I don’t know Mr. Lewis anywhere near as well as I know other members of his family, but I’m fairly convinced that he’s pretty smart.
The problem is that he has effectively removed himself from polite Jewish society. Yes, there is a small percentage of Jews who hate Israel and hate Jews that support Israel’s existence (read: Zionists), but they do not represent Judaism any more than Hamas represents Islam, or even, I suspect, ordinary Palestinians.
On Passover many Jews sit at the seder table and read and discuss the story of Passover. At one point there are four sons who are described. Mr. Lewis would be categorized as the Roshe, or wicked son, who has removed himself from the community.
So let’s get down to the nitty gritty, as Scott Ragowsky would say.
In addition to not being an expert on antisemitism, Mr. Angus is certainly no expert on Jewish law or tradition. He may be correct that Mr. Lewis is being labelled as a traitor to the community, or by his actions a Jew who endangers another Jew (or in this case several hundred thousand Canadian Jews). The NDP leader has repeatedly dismissed the concerns of most Canadian Jews about growing violence and hate, and he has done much to fuel hatred against his own people.
Where Mr. Angus is incorrect is in his interpretation of the meaning and implication of the terms rodef and mosar. It may be true that an extremist invoked those terms to justify the assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Rabin, but those terms themselves do not mandate murder.
What they do is identify Mr. Lewis as a danger to the community and as such there is an obligation to do what is necessary to stop him from hurting us. There are many ways that this can be accomplished without violence. Publicly calling out his antisemitic behaviour is one. Campaigning against him and his party so that he and the NDP are swept into the dustbin of history after the next election would be another. Reporting him to the police for hate speech could be considered. Excommunication is another tool. None of these methods are violent.
There are a lot of things referenced in ancient scripture that are no longer practiced. Jews no longer sacrifice animals before an altar. Adulterers are no longer stoned to death. Just because an extremist uses an ancient religious term to justify murder, that does not mean that all those who reference those terms advocate murder.
If Mr. Angus wants to extrapolate the intent of Yigal Amir on all Jews, does he also plan to extrapolate the evil of people who kill in the name of Islam on all Muslims? The murderous nature of Stalin’s “socialist” regime on all those who claim to be socialists (including himself)?
Mr. Angus sets a dangerous precedent when he accuses someone who uses a biblical reference in a criticism of his leader of a call to violence.
I won’t be party to that Mr. Angus.
I refuse to paint everyone with a single brush just because of the actions of a small group.
I refuse to hate all Palestinians because of what Hamas did to Israeli citizens and residents.
I refuse to hate all Muslims because of 9/11.
I refuse to hate all Germans because of the Holocaust.
I refuse to hate all Japanese people for their military’s atrocities in Korea.
I refuse to hate all Chinese people because of the country’s government’s actions in Xinjiang.
There is too much hate in the world already. Yoni Goldstein called out a man who was adding to it. He called on the Jewish community to reject that message.
Mr. Angus speaks about the lessons he learned when he took a principled stand on same sex marriage. He learned of “the importance of having people speak up so that I did not feel so alone”. Unfortunately he has chosen to speak up on behalf of someone who has, in the opinion of most Jews in Canada, committed an act of hate speech.
I choose to speak up as well. I, like many others, am speaking up for Yoni Goldstein so that he knows he is not alone. I am speaking up for the Jewish community of Canada which, believe me, feels VERY MUCH ALONE.
And I will continue to speak out against hate in all its forms.




Here is the comment I wrote. I suspect he will remove it.
————————————————————————
Jews have seen this playbook many times before when decent people are led to believe something entirely false based on spurious evidence that makes those hating Jews seem righteous and justified.
Today, it is hating the Jewish state rather than Jews directly. It is hating Zionists, in other words more than 90% of Jews. The mediaeval blood libels of Jewish blood thirstiness have been recycled and are circulated today by a closed loop created by propaganda laundered by the UN and NGO’s.
Many of your readers who commented are openly antisemitic, but most want to be socially conscious and abhor war and death. Unfortunately, between Soviet and Hamas propaganda, they have been led to believe that Hamas is justified in its resistance. Hamas spent almost 20 years in charge of the Gaza strip, spending every penny on building tunnels in which to hold hostages while they sacrificed their own innocent civilians above. They started this war by brutally raping, torturing, murdering, kidnapping, beheading and burning alive Israelis, from infants to the elderly. And yet despite this awful war 97% of Gazans are still alive and even according to the UN, their population has increased in the last three years. It is tragic, and Hamas is getting their way by having Jews vilified the world over.
I am not sure why you are reading Charlie Angus. His readers’ comments are even worse. The Jew haters commenting, apparently the vast majority of the writers, feel entirely justified and righteous invoking their mass delusion of genocide without any evidence.